Beyond proportionality: understanding the new regulatory reality
Back To Insights

Beyond proportionality: understanding the new regulatory reality

Michael Sicsic
Categories:
News

Share:

In early September, Sicsic Advisory held its Back to School webinar to examine the current regulatory climate for the UK insurance sector. The discussion covered the evolution in the regulator’s tone, the continued focus on fair value and claims, and the busy agenda facing firms. If you were not able to attend the session, we have summarised the key takeaways below.

The insurance sector faces a complex and, at times, confusing regulatory landscape. There is a clear change in the mood music from the regulators, with a new focus on proportionality and growth. This shift is aligned with the government’s agenda to foster growth and international competitiveness.

However, firms that expect a period of deregulation will be disappointed. While the language has softened, the intensity of supervision has not. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) remains active through its data-led approach to supervision and a series of significant ongoing interventions. Boards and senior managers must navigate this apparent contradiction: a call for proportionality set against a backdrop of continued assertive scrutiny. This environment demands a clear focus on demonstrating good outcomes, particularly in the critical areas of fair value and claims.

Reading the new regulatory mood music

“With the new focus of regulators on international competitiveness and growth, you can understand why the focus has shifted from assertiveness to proportionality of regulation… it’s important to make sure that regulation does not confer a disproportionate burden on the regulated.” – David Otudeko, Director of Regulation at the Association of British Insurers (ABI) said at the webinar.

Evidence of this shift can be seen in recent regulatory actions. The terms of reference for the pure protection market study were modified to acknowledge the importance of growth and a protection gap. Similarly, the FCA’s ‘Roadmap for Retail Insurance’ demonstrated a change in regulatory language and a preference for targeted, firm-specific interventions over market-wide ones. The interim report on the premium finance market study also discarded sector-wide remedies for now, focusing on outliers instead.

Despite this change in tone, supervisory activity continues at pace. Large and sophisticated firms remain under close scrutiny, with some facing redress exercises. The FCA also uses its data-led capabilities to conduct reactive supervision across a broader segment of the market. Firms of a more modest size are receiving questions and facing interventions based on the regulator’s internal data reviews. This activity is happening alongside major ongoing workstreams, including the premium finance and pure protection market studies.

Fair value: a focus on outcomes, not process

Product governance and fair value are now established concepts. For the general insurance sector, firms are now in their fourth iteration of Fair Value Assessments (FVAs). The time for ‘bedding in’ is over: the FCA’s thematic review in August 2024 gave the industry a ‘very disappointed grade’ and demanded improvements.

Firms must now move beyond ‘box-ticking’ compliance and instead focus on efficiency and substance. The regulator has been clear that it is not interested in lengthy, hundred-page documents that fail to identify or address issues. Instead, it expects shorter, sharper reviews that demonstrate genuine critical analysis, identify outliers, and drive tangible decisions and actions.

“I’d say substance, over volume. The FCA talked about using critical analysis to produce a proportionate, focused review that drives decisions and actions.” – added Sue Mallender.

The key question for any FVA should be, ‘so what?’. Does the assessment provide meaningful insight into the value of the product and lead to operational change?

The FCA is attempting to provide more clarity on roles and responsibilities through its consultation on simplifying insurance rules (CP25/12). One proposal is the concept of a ‘lead manufacturer’ where co-manufacturing exists, which could reduce duplication. However, the consultation currently proposes that only an insurer can take this role, which ignores the reality of how many Managing General Agents (MGAs) operate under delegated authority. It remains to be seen how the FCA will respond to industry feedback on this point.

While the consultation clarifies that distributors do not need to second-guess or repeat the manufacturer’s assessment, they are not absolved of responsibility. Distributors must still compare products to ensure they meet their customers’ demands and needs. They also have a responsibility to assess how their own remuneration and fees impact the overall value delivered to the end customer.

The unresolved question of commission

A recurring area of regulatory scrutiny is remuneration, particularly, percentage-based commission models. A persistent myth holds that a commission rate below 50% is inherently acceptable. The FCA’s work on multi-occupancy building insurance shows this is not the case. The regulator expects firms to justify the pound amount of remuneration, not just the percentage. In a market of rising premiums, a fixed percentage can lead to higher absolute commissions without any corresponding increase in the services provided or cost to serve, making it difficult to justify. In terms of percentage-based commission where it’s unjustified, uncapped and undisclosed, there’s going to be a problem.

Firms must also be alert to ‘double dipping’, where a distributor justifies its commission based on the services it provides, and then charges separate fees for the same services. The core principle is simple: can they justify that the total remuneration received is commensurate with the service provided?

The recent Supreme Court judgment on motor finance adds another dimension to this issue. While the case was specific to motor finance, it highlights factors that could contribute to an ‘unfair relationship’, including the size and nature of the commission and the transparency of disclosures. The FCA intends to consult on a potential consumer redress scheme in this area. The read-across to the wider insurance market is not yet clear, but it signals the regulator’s continued focus on business models where intermediary remuneration may lead to poor value for the end customer. For manufacturers, this reinforces the need for effective oversight of the entire distribution chain.

Claims: the real test of the Consumer Duty

If a product’s value is assessed at the point of sale, that value is ultimately proven at the point of claim. The FCA published its review of home and travel claims handling this summer.

“The review of home and travel claims handling … really shows the Duty in action across the lifecycle and why claims handling is the real test.” – Claire Charlton said.

The regulator found examples of both good and poor practice, and voiced its concern that some firms were ‘not meeting their obligations under the Duty and failing to consistently deliver good outcomes’. The report highlighted several areas requiring improvement:

  • Oversight of outsourcing: Firms must take reasonable care to supervise outsourced activities. Weaknesses were found where firms had limited control over outsourced arrangements, particularly among UK branches of overseas insurers. The message is clear: regulatory responsibility cannot be outsourced. Insurers retain full accountability for the outcomes their customers receive.
  • Management Information (MI): Some firms used poor quality MI that was not focused on customer outcomes. MI must be sufficient to monitor claims handling effectively and identify trends, including specific monitoring for vulnerable customers.
  • Policy clarity: The review found that policy limits and exclusions, particularly around storm damage definitions, were not well understood by customers, leading to rejected claims. The FCA has asked trade bodies to work on this issue before the winter.
  • Cash settlements: Some firms promoted cash settlements without adequate controls or consideration of customer vulnerability. These must be monitored to ensure they are suitable and deliver good outcomes.

The upcoming publication of the 2024 GI Value Measures data will further amplify this scrutiny. Low claims acceptance rates and high complaint levels are clear indicators of poor value and increase the risk of FCA intervention.

A busy road ahead

Beyond the major thematic reviews, firms must also manage a full agenda of other regulatory initiatives: from the consultation on simplifying the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) to significant enhancements to complaints reporting, from changes to the redress system to new proposals for operational resilience incident and third-party reporting. Even where these initiatives are aimed at simplification, they still represent change and additional workload that firms must integrate into their operations.

  • SM&CR and the SMF7 role: The review of the SM&CR is part of a wider government drive to simplify the regime. While the aim is to reduce administrative burdens, the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) is also using the opportunity to extend the scope of the SMF7 roles to get better oversight of the group context, particularly regarding people with influence on the business. This is seen as a way for the PRA to make the regime more efficient while a simplification process is in place.
  • Climate change: While the political focus is moving away from climate change and ESG, they remain a top priority for the regulators. In May 2025, the PRA published a consultation on updates to its supervisory statement on climate financial risk, which includes more prescriptive requirements in some areas. The regulator is pushing this topic, and it is here to stay. The move to a less prescriptive approach places the onus on firms to define their sustainability strategy and demonstrate compliance with principles and objectives.
  • Solvent exit planning: The PRA has introduced a new requirement for insurers to have solvent exit plans. This regulation, which already exists for banks, is seen as a way to ensure an orderly market exit and protect policyholders. The process of creating these plans can also provide valuable insights into a firm’s operational resilience and business readiness. The new rules will be in force from 30 June 2026 and require firms to produce a Solvent Exit Analysis (SEA) as part of their business-as-usual activities.

The regulatory mood may be shifting towards proportionality, but the volume of work and the level of scrutiny remain high. The move from prescriptive rules to a more principles-based approach places the onus on firms to define, evidence, and deliver good outcomes.

“This is the world we are living in; maybe less prescription, but principles and objectives stay the same.” – Michael Sicsic.

In this environment, effective governance and risk management are not just a regulatory requirement – they are a constant and critical foundation for a sustainable business.

You can watch the webinar with Managing Partner Michael Sicsic, Senior Consultants Sue Mallender and Claire Charlton, and David Otudeko, Director of Regulation at the Association of British Insurers (ABI) here.